| Grant Bennati | 2023 | Eastern Nazarene College | NCAA D3 |
| Briggs Bent | 2023 | University of South Carolina Sumter | NCAA D2 |
| Dominic Phanco | 2021 | University of California Santa Barbara | NCAA D1 |
| Jose Izarra | 2022 | CD Colonia Moscardo | Collegiate Abroad |
| Asher Rosen | 2023 | Fairfield University | NCAA D1 |
| Angelo Montoya | 2023 | Francis Marion University | NCAA D2 |
| Kieran Lucas | 2024 | New College of Florida | NAIA |
| Dylan Smith | 2021 | Saint Leo University | NCAA D2 |
| Jason Piurowski | 2018 | Thomas University | NAIA |
| Dylan Dana | 2023 | Florida Gulf Coast University | NCAA D1 |
| Jacob Rocha | 2022 | Pfeiffer College | NCAA D2 |
| Santiago Castaneda | 2021 | Duisburg FC | Professional |
| Raleigh Wilson | 2023 | Aurora University | NCAA D3 |
| Jake lauer | 2023 | Brevard College | NCAA D3 |
| Asher Jones | 2024 | University of South Florida | NCAA D1 |
| Ethan Sternberg | 2021 | Averett University | NCAA D3 |
| Wade Aller | 2024 | Averett University | NCAA D3 |
| Jordan Proulx | 2021 | Rollins College | NCAA D2 |
| Mick Stauffer | 2023 | Daytona State College | NJCAA |
| Jaime McFarland | 2024 | Colorado College | NCAA D3 |
| Brandan Noorgard | 2023 | University of Central Lancashire | Collegiate Abroad |
| Gabriel Herrera | 2021 | University of Tampa | NCAA D2 |
| Lars Legg | 2021 | Lake Erie University | NCAA D2 |
| George Obregon | 2022 | North Greenville University | NCAA D2 |
| Santiago Jaramillo | 2023 | Francis Marion University | NCAA D2 |
| Nate Nkanji | 2023 | Philadelphia Union | Professional |
| Sebas Rengifo | 2023 | Francis Marion University | NCAA D2 |
| AJ Misemer | 2023 | Jacksonville University | NCAA D1 |
| Eddie Montalvo | 2023 | Eckerd College | NCAA D2 |
| Seth Tarbox | 2021 | Warner University | NAIA |
| Brock Mantei | 2021 | Averett University | NCAA D3 |
| Matt Risso | 2023 | Wofford College | NCAA D1 |
| Sean Corcoran | 2023 | Emory and Henry College | NCAA D2 |
| Nicolás Cubas | 2024 | University of Tampa | NCAA D2 |
| Nicholas Griner | 2023 | Lagrange College | NCAA D3 |
| Max Moon | 2020 | St Leo University | NCAA D2 |
| Kai Lindsey | 2025 | North Greenville University | NCAA D2 |
| Colin Bailey | 2022 | N/A | N/A |
| Justin Koerner | 2023 | University of Hawaii at Hilo | NCAA D2 |
| Julian Rosario-Torres | 2023 | Saint Leo University | NCAA D2 |
| Luke Hunter | 2023 | Sewanee College | NCAA D3 |
